Maintaining that the
Indo-US Joint Statement was a "continuation of the
pro-US shift" in foreign policy, major Left parties
today said the agreement not only "marks an end" of
India's nuclear disarmament policy but also does not
serve its interests in spreading democracy or
combating terrorism.
Observing that no
"adequate discussions" were held with UPA partners or
the Left parties before the Government entered into
the latest agreements with Washington, the CPI(M) and
CPI said Washington also did not make any clear-cut
commitment on India's quest for permanent membership
of the UN Security Council.
Maintaining that the
announcement of US-India Global Democracy Initiative
to strengthen democracy in third countries "must be
viewed with skepticism", the CPI(M) Polit Bureau said
in a statement that such a bilateral initiative
"displays the anxiety of India to align with the US at
a time when the superpower has become notorious for
its unilateralist and anti-democratic activities".
It would have been better
if such initiative was taken through the United
Nations, the party said adding that it would be better
if the Government realised that a major aspect of
global terrorism today was the use of state terrorism
and the gross violation of national sovereignty as
amply demonstrated in the case of Iraq.
On the nuclear cooperation
issue, the major Left party said "it was incumbent on
the Government to place their views and proposals for
discussion with all the parties concerned before
deciding on the course of action.
"Many security and foreign
policy issues were negotiated secretly during the NDA
regime through the Strobe Talbott- Jaswant Singh
negotiations. The UPA Government should not continue
the undemocratic practice", the CPI(M) said.
Asserting that it had
opposed the erstwhile NDA Government's nuclear
weaponisation programme, it said the Left had
consistently supported an independent nuclear policy.
"India had always opposed
the discriminatory policies of the nuclear haves and
havenots. It was also committed to nuclear disarmament
and making the world free of nuclear weapons. The
Rajiv Gandhi plan for disarmament was the last major
initiative taken in this regard", the party said.
Charging the NDA regime
with having begun the process of "accepting junior
partnership of the US in return for a de facto
recognition as a nuclear weapon state without
acquiring a legitimate position in the nuclear club",
the CPI(M) said "the current agreement marks an end to
India's nuclear disarmament policy".
It said there were
"legitimate apprehensions" that restrictions,
hampering the pursuit of an independent nuclear
technology policy for peaceful purposes, would be
imposed. "There is also the question whether research
activities for overcoming reliance on import of
nuclear fuel will be hampered".
Asking the Government to
"carefully calibrate its steps strictly in response to
measures taken by the US", the CPI(M) said it expected
the Government "not to undertake unilateral measures
which may compromise national interests".
On the issues of energy
and environment, it said it was the US which had
"refused to sign the Kyoto protocol and is placing
obstacles for working towards using cleaner and more
efficient technologies".
The CPI(M) also pointed
out that the Joint Statement and the various briefings
were "silent about what the US has got in return for
offering civilian nuclear cooperation.
"The Government should
clarify whether there has been an understanding
reached about buying US defence equipment to the tune
of billions of dollars", it said adding that the Left
parties had already opposed the purchase of F-16
fighter jets.
In a separate statement,
the CPI Central Secretariat also made similar points
saying that Washington had neither supported India's
claim for Security Council seat, nor recognised it has
a nuclear weapons power," but merely as a state with
advanced nuclear technology".
In return for these
ambiguous and limited assurances, India has agreed to
continue its unilateral moratorium on N-tests,
separate its civilian and military nuclear facilities
and open its civilian facilities for international
inspection.
"The CPI strongly believes
that this Joint Statement is a continuation of the
pro-US shift in India's foreign policy that was
initiated by the Vajpayee regime and carried forward
by the Indo-US Defence Framework", it said, adding
that this marked a deviation from the non-alignment
policy and the CMP.